I have recently encountered several individuals who have told me that their reenacting activities have been restricted by the Sons of Confederate Veterans. Apparently, some camps have decided that reenacting the “Yankee Scourge” is demeaning to the individual, & disrespectful to the honored memory of Confederate Soldiers. Most recently, I was contacted by a man who wanted to join us, but said that he was a SCV member & was only allowed to reenact as a Confederate (I told him that if this was the case, he needed to find another unit).
Should my next statements go beyond our unit, I have no doubt that I will be called everything from a rotten Scalawag, to a Christ denying, One World government type. So be it. Bully’s & nitwits need to be confronted.
I am a proud Southerner. A proud Southern Soldier. My heroes & role models are Lee & Jackson. I try my darndest to live up to the high expectations of the Southern Warrior/Gentleman ideal (yes, I know I fall short). I have always held the South, her struggle for independence & the gallant men who carried her freedom upon their bayonets in high regard. Having said that… The SCV can go jump in the lake.
I resent these self appointed keepers of “Southern Heritage” trying to impose their rules on our hobby & our unit Do they truly think that it reflects honor on the memory of Southern soldiers to see them driven off the field by half a dozen Yankees? No they don’t. They don’t realize that it is important that we galvanize. Further, they don’t care. They do not (as a general rule) reenact, they care nothing for our hobby. They are trying to make some grandiose political statement. We are not less Southern because we portray the 1st Michigan/17th Michigan.
The SCV has come to us before asking for our help. More often than not, we have supplied it. I have never been given so much as a thank you. I guess we were privileged to support them. The SCV has never contributed one thin dime to our coffers. They have never sent even one man to help us maintain or crew the gun. We have volunteered to play blue at several of their sponsored events. I really did not expect their gratitude. However the consistently bad treatment & faint contempt we were/are treated with when wearing Federal Uniforms is unbelievable.
I am done helping/supporting the SCV in any way. If we are at an event, & actions can be taken that are mutually beneficial, fine. But I will not go even a half of a hair out of my way for them. I will not turn away any member because of SCV affiliation. But, We are an independent unit, & I not bend, even one inch, to their desires or demands.
Y.O.S.
Duke
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I TOTALLY agree. Yes, I am a transplanted Yankee, but you gentlemen and ladies have warmly and lovingly welcomed me into your unit - and in some cames, your lives. I thank you. Apparantly some folks have forgotten that this is a hobby and that we should be reenacting history - not refighting the battle. I will continue to give my support to CFA.
ReplyDeleteChaplain,
ReplyDeleteI got your e-mail on the revolving carbine. I have looked at those. They are pretty cool, & see a good amount of use among cowboy action shooters. Regretably, they were introduced after the War of Northern aggression...
If I may be so bold as to add, I know not what other camps do, however as to the Son's of Confederate Camp of Coats, North Carolina (The Black River Tigers). Almost all member of that camp are members of the Edenton Bell Battery Living History Group. I can attest to it that they as needed doff the grey and don the blue. I am happy to report that I am not a member of a camp full of hybris. As the Good Book says in Ecclesiastes there is a time for everthing and it is for us to seek his guidance as to the proper direction. A battlefield reenactment as I perceive it to be is where the participants work to ensure a sence of realism to lend itseft to the honor of those who gave that last full measure of debotion and passed over to that undescoverd country. So it would behoove the participants to be willing to portray the opposing contestas on the field of honor and mortal combat.
ReplyDeleteRespectfully, YOS
Benajah Eure